Categories: Breaking NewsHealthNewsScience

Myrtle Beach Irish Pub Faces Federal Lawsuit Over Music Licensing Issues

Interior of a busy Irish pub with patrons enjoying music

News Summary

The Ole Irish Pub, known as The Irish Exit, is facing a federal lawsuit from BMI for allegedly playing copyrighted music without proper licensing. The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court, highlights the challenges small businesses face regarding music licensing requirements. The pub’s owners reportedly ignored numerous communications from BMI about the issue, leading to legal action seeking statutory damages. This case serves as a crucial reminder for venues about the importance of complying with copyright laws.

Myrtle Beach Irish Pub Faces Federal Lawsuit Over Music Licensing Issues

In the charming town of Myrtle Beach, The Ole Irish Pub, known as The Irish Exit, finds itself in hot water after a lawsuit was filed against the establishment by Broadcast Music Inc. (BMI). The legal action comes as a shock to many fans of the lively pub, which has been a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike to enjoy a pint while listening to some of their favorite tunes.

What’s the Hullabaloo?

Filed in U.S. District Court on April 7, 2025, the lawsuit accuses the pub’s owners, James and Theresa Byrne, of allowing the public performance of copyrighted music without the necessary licenses. While enjoying an evening of lively music and good cheer, patrons likely didn’t realize that behind the scenes, the pub was allegedly playing five popular songs without any legal backing. The tracks in question? Well, among them are classic favorites like “Family Tradition” by Hank Williams Jr., “Neon Moon” by Ronnie Dunn, and “Higher” by Creed, crafted by Scott Stapp and Mark Tremonti.

More Than Just a One-Off Issue

It’s worth noting that The Irish Exit is not alone in facing scrutiny from BMI. The pub is just one of at least two establishments along the picturesque Grand Strand currently caught up in copyright infringement claims this year. Earlier this January, another bar in Pawleys Island was hit with a similar lawsuit. As the music scene continues to thrive in the area, it’s clear that the stakes are high for those operating venues that showcase live or recorded music.

The Bitter Cost of Music Licensing

BMI is a recognized performance rights organization that advocates for songwriters and collects licensing fees on behalf of artists. Businesses that play music from BMI’s extensive catalog, which boasts over 22 million works, are required to obtain a license. The onus to secure this license falls on the business itself, meaning venues like The Irish Exit are responsible for compliance, not the performers.

For small bars, obtaining a music license can be relatively affordable, with costs generally ranging from $300 to $400 annually. However, depending on the venue’s size and the type of music played, fees can skyrocket up to ¤2,000. This could pose a hefty financial challenge for independent establishments just trying to create a vibrant atmosphere for their patrons.

BMI’s Attempts to Resolve the Matter

In its legal filing, BMI claims that since May 2022, it has made over 50 separate communications with The Irish Exit regarding this ongoing copyright issue. These attempts to resolve the matter included cease-and-desist letters urging the pub to cease performances of BMI music, which went unheeded. Despite numerous notifications and warnings, the alleged infringement seemingly continued, prompting the organization to take this serious step by resorting to legal action.

What’s Next for The Irish Exit?

The lawsuit seeks not just to halt any unlicensed music performances at The Irish Exit but also aims to recover statutory damages and cover legal costs associated with the litigation. The case highlights the crucial nature of adhering to copyright laws for those in the entertainment and hospitality industries, especially in areas frequented by music enthusiasts.

As of now, The Irish Exit has not made any comments regarding the lawsuit, leaving many curious about how the pub plans to navigate this legal storm. Locals and regulars alike will no doubt be watching closely as this situation unfolds, reminding everyone that while music may bring joy, it also comes with responsibilities.

In conclusion, as Myrtle Beach continues to celebrate its rich musical culture, this lawsuit serves as a timely reminder about the importance of proper licensing for all who love to share the gift of music with others. Whether it’s a small pub or a large venue, everyone involved in the business of entertainment must remain vigilant to avoid falling foul of copyright laws.